Tam looks for clues from Madame Julie's card reading and finds an unlikely answer. Deena confesses to Chelsi only to find she already knew the truth and is mad at her. Mandy fights to keep afloat as her youngest boy rocks the boat.
In New York, Deena is dreading Andy's birthday where the whole family knows he was unfaithful. Down in Florida, Paul gaslights Tam, throwing her into a frenzy before therapy. In Illinois, the devil is trying to ruin Mandy and Jeff's dinner party.
Tam and Paul have a couples reading that reveals Paul must make a choice. Deena has Savannah's boyfriend over for dinner to get to know him. Mandy adjusts to her rigorous schedule at home with four kids and working on Jeff's Marriage More venture.
Tam and Paul get ready for the annual costume party that always ends in disaster. Andy is enraged when Deena's hurt feelings threaten their business partnership. Jeff helps Mandy get a break only to realize how hard her day-to-days really are.
Paul stumbles back into Tam's life, testing her resolve to say goodbye. Andy must make a major sacrifice to save his marriage with Deena. Jeff and Mandy take a night off in hopes of reigniting their passion.
Two professional lumberjacks tie the knot and Buddy makes a tree inspired wedding cake. Plus, Carlo’s Bake Shop gives back to Feeding America and Buddy promises an amazing meal for all the volunteers at the Hoboken shelter.
Buddy and his family snow tube in the Poconos. Meanwhile, Mary and Carlo’s team make a cake for a zoo to celebrate the Chinese Year of the Monkey. Buddy Castano is getting ready for college, but Mauro and Madeline are having a hard time letting go.
The bakery has gone mad, hatter that is! When Buddy is asked to make an Alice in Wonderland cake for a children's theater, he falls deep into the rabbit hole. Mauro creates a vintage baseball themed cake for the Carlos Beltran Foundation.
A family needs a cake for an upcoming quinceanera celebration. Plus, a cake that's for the dogs... or at least the dog groomers. Then, Buddy and Lisa go head to head over their son Marco playing football.
Buddy heads to Meadowlands Racetrack where they are asked to make a cake for the infamous camel and ostrich races. The bakery also receives a visit from a few families with the Make-a-Wish foundation.
Buddy and the crew get wrapped up in their work by creating a cake of an ancient Egyptian mummy sarcophagus. And, Mauro, Joe, Danny and Frankie make a pancake cake. Mauro's jalapeno bacon cake filling flavor choice may be a little too hot to handle.
Sugar and spice and everything... meat? Buddy makes a giant hot dog cake for the famous 4th of July hot dog eating contest at Coney Island. An order for a BBQ pit master has Joe attempting a pork belly cake filling.
An Indian couple asks for an exact replica of the Taj Mahal, but the intricate design may be more than Buddy and his team can handle. Grace helps a couple of boys ask their girlfriends to prom with an over-the-top surprise 'Promposal' cake.
The professional soccer team F.C. Internazionale is in Hoboken from Italy, and Buddy and the guys are making them a cake. It's a dream come true for Mauro and Danny, who have been fans since childhood. Mary dips her toes in becoming a foot model.
Buddy makes a cake for an all female motorcycle club. These women want a cake that's feminine, but tough, just like them. Plus, the team goes girlie to make the perfect, pink princess cake for one lucky little 5-year-old.