Mary's shunning by the Amish Church continues, due to attending Andrew’s wedding. Abe and Rebecca don’t feel connected to the Amish community while Jeremiah and Katie Ann are trying to live by the rules. Kate goes for a very NEW look.
Will Mary’s dream of running a Bed and Breakfast bring the Schmuckers emotionally together? Chapel gets the courage to confront Mary. It's all too much as Mary's poor health finally catches up with her.
Everyone anxiously waits for news on Mary while Kate rushes to Punxsutawney to be with her. Back at the Bed and Breakfast, Chester comes to give his opinion on the place and out-of-towners pop in too early. Jeremiah deals with an unwelcome presence.
Mary receives unexpected guests before the B&B opens. She puts them through a REAL Amish experience that they never anticipated. Rebecca confronts Jeremiah, which forces him to reach out to Katie Ann.
Kate saves the day when a guest arrives at the B&B. Abe helps an Amish guy into an English lifestyle. Kate and Rebecca help Mary become healthier. Chapel visits Andrew while Katie Ann makes a major decision at the Rodeo.
Kate lands a fashion show and sets up a photo-shoot with Mary’s help at the B&B. Katie Ann settles into her new English life with Abe and Rebecca. Later, Abe and Rebecca discover a secret that Jeremiah has been hiding.
Jeremiah visits his kids in Ohio and Katie Ann makes a big change in her life. The church pressures Mary to shut down the B&B. Chapel seeks Mary’s advice on her relationship with Andrew while Kate returns to NYC to reveal her fashion line.
Mary heads to NYC to visit Kate and gets a bit more than she bargained for. Katie Ann returns to support Mary and clean the B&B. Chapel visits Andrew and Jeremiah gets into trouble with the law.
Everyone comes together to support Mary during a time of crisis and help her with a new start; Kate looks for new ways to establish herself in the New York City fashion world; Sabrina's return triggers an emotional reaction from Abe and Rebecca.
The whole gang takes a road trip to New York City to surprise Kate and revisit old memories; Jeremiah reveals to Sabrina about his long distance relationship; Mary secretly sends for help from Punxsutawney.
Mary brings her youngest daughter, Esther to New York City causing Rebecca to act negatively; Abe must decide if the cost of his impending dental work is worth compromising his Amish beliefs.
Sabrina overcomes nerves to speak in front of a NYU class; Tension between Rebecca and Sabrina escalates; Esther makes a deal with Mary to experience English life.
Mary makes an Amish meal to bring everyone together and make peace; Jeremiah spends time with his kids in New York City; Rebecca and Abe discuss her job at the bakery; Sabrina goes on a special date.
The cast returns to Lancaster to celebrate Amish Old Christmas with Mary; Kate receives some unsettling news about her internship; Jeremiah confronts Kate during dinner.